Compassionate courage in small businesses: why it is fair, and necessary, to make room for new capability

A Smart Roots Consulting white paper · @Gurbinder Punn · Oct 22, 2026

Gurbinder Singh Punn — Founder & CEO, Smart Roots Consulting


Executive summary

In small businesses, the owner’s loyalty to early employees often becomes the single biggest brake on growth. The people who carried the firm through its hardest years are not always the people who can carry it into the next stage — and pretend otherwise is unkind to everyone, including them.

Across our work with owner-led firms of 20 people or fewer in the UAE, Oman and India, we see the same pattern. An owner keeps a long-tenured employee whose skills and behaviors have stayed where they were ten or fifteen years ago, while the business has moved on. The reasons sound humane: “I don’t terminate people, I coach them,” “he stood by me,” “it would be unfair.” In practice the cost lands on the owner, the rest of the team, the customers — and often on the employee, who is quietly sidelined rather than honestly helped.

This paper argues for compassionate courage: be generous, honest and fair with people, but do not let that generosity cost you the business. Coaching is the first answer, not the only one. When a genuine, time-bound development effort has not closed the gap, it is right — and responsible — to let a person go with dignity and bring new capability into the system.

We draw on organizational research (Greiner, Staw, Rousseau, Felps, Gómez-Mejía), management writers (Collins, Goldsmith, Horowitz, Scott, Brown, McCord, Hoffman) and practitioner case evidence, and close with a practical framework and diagnostic questions owners can use this quarter.

1. The pattern: when the business grows and the person does not

The firm has outgrown the role-holder; the role-holder has not outgrown the firm. That asymmetry, left unaddressed, is the loyalty trap.

A typical composite from our client work (details changed): a trading company in the Middle East, 16 people, founded 2009. Its first accountant joined when the owner ran the business from one room. He worked unpaid overtime through a cash-flow crisis in 2015 and is trusted completely. Today the company needs ERP-based reporting, VAT compliance, cash-flow forecasting and a finance function that can talk to banks. He still keeps ledgers in spreadsheets, resists new systems, and routes every decision through the owner. Two capable junior hires have left in three years. The owner says, “I can’t do that to him.”

The recognisable features:

  • Frozen capability. Skills and behaviours set for the firm of year one, not year fifteen.
  • Role creep around the person. Work is quietly routed away from them; new hires absorb the gap; the owner does the rest personally.
  • Status without accountability. Tenure confers informal authority, so the person is rarely challenged and often blocks change.
  • A story of debt. “He was there when no one else was” — gratitude is treated as a lifetime contract.
  • “Nice” as a management philosophy. “I don’t fire, I coach” — sincerely held, but often with no defined goal, timeline or consequence.

Larry Greiner’s classic Harvard Business Review model of organisational growth explains why this happens. Firms move through stages, and each stage ends in a crisis that demands new practices and new capabilities. The “crisis of leadership” that ends the founder-led creative phase is precisely the point at which early, generalist, loyal contributors are asked to become specialists, managers or system-builders — and many cannot or will not make the shift (Greiner, 1972; 1998). As Marshall Goldsmith puts it in the title of his best-known book, what got you here won’t get you there.

2. Why owners hold on

Owners don’t avoid these decisions because they are weak; they avoid them because several well-documented forces push in the same direction at once.

Escalation of commitment. Barry Staw’s research shows that people who are personally responsible for an earlier decision tend to invest more in it when it is failing, to justify the original choice (Staw, 1976; Staw & Ross, 1987). An owner who hired, trained and defended someone for 15 years is the textbook case. Each year of tolerance makes the next year easier to justify.

Socioemotional wealth. Research on family and owner-managed firms finds that owners value non-financial returns — identity, belonging, a sense of the firm as “family” — and will accept lower financial performance to protect them (Gómez-Mejía et al., 2007). Letting an early employee go feels like losing part of the firm’s identity, not just a role-holder.

The unwritten psychological contract. Denise Rousseau’s work describes the implicit promises employees and employers believe they have made each other (Rousseau, 1989; 1995). In small firms these are rarely written down: “you stood by me, so I’ll always look after you.” Owners fear that breaking this unwritten promise makes them unfair — even when the promise was never realistic.

Relationship over role — the founder’s dilemma. Noam Wasserman’s study of nearly 10,000 founders found that hiring friends, family and early loyalists is common, and that those relationships make later role changes far harder and more emotionally costly (Wasserman, 2012). He frames it as a choice between keeping control and comfort, and building a more valuable company.

Ruinous empathy. Kim Scott’s Radical Candor names the most common management failure: caring personally about someone but failing to challenge them directly (Scott, 2017). It feels kind. It isn’t — the person never gets the honest information they need to change.

The owner’s own part. Honesty cuts both ways. Manzoni and Barsoux’s “set-up-to-fail syndrome” shows that once a manager decides someone is a weak performer, they often micromanage, withhold stretch work and lower expectations — which then produces the weak performance they expected (Manzoni & Barsoux, 1998). Many long-tenured employees were never given clear new expectations, training or feedback as the business changed. The owner’s guilt is sometimes a signal that this part of the job hasn’t been done yet.

3. The hidden cost of staying

The cost of keeping someone the business has outgrown is rarely visible on a P&L, but in a firm of 20 it is felt by everyone, every week.

Who pays How it shows up
The owner Becomes the workaround: re-checks work, absorbs tasks, stays operational instead of strategic. Growth stalls at the owner’s personal bandwidth.
High performers Carry the gap, see no consequence, and leave. Collins found that great companies treated tolerance of weak performers as unfair to the best people (Collins, 2001).
Team norms Felps, Mitchell and Byington (2006) showed that a single member who withholds effort or resists can pull down the whole group’s performance and behaviour — the “bad apple” effect. Small teams have no buffer.
Customers Quality, speed and responsiveness are set by the weakest link in a short chain.
The culture Every tolerated gap teaches the rest of the team what the real standard is. As Australian Army chief David Morrison put it, the standard you walk past is the standard you accept.
The employee Kept but sidelined, stripped of meaningful work, quietly resented — and denied the honest feedback that might have helped them move on to a role where they could thrive.

Scale matters. In a 15-person company, one role is roughly 7% of total capacity; in a key role — finance, operations, sales lead — the effect is far larger. Big firms can dilute a capability gap. Small firms cannot.

Ben Horowitz describes this as a moment when the company outgrows the person. He argues the kindest thing a leader can do is name it clearly and take responsibility for it, rather than let the person discover their irrelevance slowly (Horowitz, 2014).

4. Reframing kindness: empathy without abdication

Real kindness is measured by what happens to people, not by how comfortable the owner feels. Several leading thinkers make the same point in different words.

  • Clear is kind. Brené Brown’s research on courageous leadership concludes that unclear expectations and avoided conversations are a form of unkindness, because they leave people guessing (Brown, 2018). Saying nothing is not neutral.
  • Care and challenge together. Kim Scott’s Radical Candor model holds that caring personally and challenging directly are not opposites; the most respected leaders do both (Scott, 2017). Coaching without challenge is just companionship.
  • Loyalty to the mission, not the seat. Reid Hoffman, Ben Casnocha and Chris Yeh propose treating employment as an alliance built on “tours of duty” — explicit, time-bound commitments with mutual benefit (Hoffman et al., 2014). Honouring someone’s past tour does not oblige you to extend it indefinitely.
  • The keeper test. Netflix asks managers: if this person told me they were leaving, would I fight to keep them? If not, a generous exit is better for both sides (McCord, 2017; Hastings & Meyer, 2020). Owners of small firms need not adopt Netflix’s intensity to benefit from the question.
  • Right people, right seats. Jim Collins framed the issue as “first who, then what”: get the right people on the bus and in the right seats before deciding direction (Collins, 2001). His test is blunt — knowing what you know now, would you hire this person again?

In the relationship-centred business cultures of the Gulf and South Asia, these ideas need adapting, not abandoning. Respect, face and long-standing bonds matter. That argues for more care in how a decision is made and communicated — privately, respectfully, with generous support — not for avoiding the decision.

Gratitude is real and should be honoured. But gratitude is paid in respect, recognition and a fair exit — not in a role the business can no longer afford.

5. A framework: coach first, then decide

“I coach, I don’t fire” becomes a strength once coaching has a goal, a timeline and a consequence. We use a five-step path with owners; it turns an emotional dilemma into a fair, time-bound process.

Coach-then-decide path · 5 steps, 3 outcomes

Every path runs through a decision: coaching either closes the gap, or opens a fair conversation about a different seat or a dignified exit.

  1. Define the role the business needs now. Write down the outcomes, skills and behaviours required in this seat for the next two to three years — not the job as it was. Many long-tenured employees have never seen this in writing.
  2. Assess honestly — skill, will and setup. Is the gap one of capability (can’t yet), motivation (won’t), or environment (was never asked, trained or given authority)? Check the owner’s own role first; the set-up-to-fail pattern is common in founder-led firms.
  3. Coach with a contract. Agree a 60- to 90-day development plan with three to five measurable outcomes, named support (training, a coach, a mentor, tools), and fortnightly reviews. Goldsmith’s stakeholder-centred approach — asking colleagues for feedforward and following up visibly — works well here (Goldsmith, 2007). State at the start what happens if the outcomes are not met.
  4. Decide on the evidence. At the end of the period, one of three outcomes follows:
    • Grow — the gap closed; reset expectations and keep developing.
    • Re-seat — a different role exists that the business genuinely needs and the person can do well, at pay that matches the role. Not a made-up title.
    • Release — the gap remains; agree a dignified, well-supported exit.
  5. Renew the system. Bring in the capability the business needs, onboard it properly, and use the vacancy to redesign the role around the firm’s next stage.

Two rules keep the process honest. First, no indefinite extensions: one extension, if any, with a new date. Second, the owner documents the journey — not to build a case, but so both sides can see that the effort was real.

6. Letting go with dignity

How an exit is handled matters as much as the decision itself — to the person leaving, and to everyone who stays and watches.

Research on organisational justice is consistent. People judge an exit by three things: whether the outcome is fair (distributive justice), whether the process was fair (procedural justice), and whether they were treated with respect and honesty (interactional justice) (Bies & Moag, 1986). Brockner’s studies of layoffs found that the remaining employees’ commitment depends heavily on how fairly and humanely colleagues were treated on the way out (Brockner, 1994).

Practical principles for owners:

  • The owner has the conversation. Not HR, not a letter, not a manager. After years of loyalty, the person deserves to hear it from you, privately and in person.
  • Be clear in the first two minutes. State the decision and the reason simply. Long preambles are for the speaker’s comfort, not the listener’s.
  • Be generous beyond the legal minimum where you can. Extended notice or pay in lieu, the full end-of-service entitlement paid promptly, continued medical cover for a period, outplacement or coaching support, and a strong reference.
  • Protect their story. Agree together how the departure is described to the team and clients. Let them leave as a respected contributor, not a problem solved.
  • Honour the contribution publicly. A proper farewell signals to the team that loyalty is valued — and that standards apply to everyone.
  • Use your network. Owners often know where this person’s experience would be valued. A warm introduction can be the most useful gift.
  • Get the law right. Requirements differ across Oman (Labour Law, Royal Decree 53/2023), the UAE (Federal Decree-Law No. 33 of 2021) and India (state Shops and Establishments Acts and other labour codes), and for nationals versus expatriates. Take local legal advice before acting.

Done this way, many people later describe a well-handled exit as the push they needed. Done badly, it confirms the owner’s worst fear — that letting go is cruel.

7. Diagnostic questions for owners

If you answer “no” to three or more of these about a long-tenured team member, it is time to start the five-step path.

  • ☐ Knowing what I know now, would I hire this person for this role today?
  • ☐ If they resigned tomorrow, would I fight to keep them — or feel relief?
  • ☐ Have they learned a significant new skill in the last two years?
  • ☐ Do newer team members want to work with them, or around them?
  • ☐ Could the business reach its three-year goals with this role performed exactly as it is today?
  • ☐ Have I told them clearly, in writing, what the role now requires?
  • ☐ Have I given them real support and a fair deadline to close the gap?
  • ☐ Am I keeping them for the business’s sake, or for my own comfort?

The last three questions are about the owner. They are often the most revealing.

Conclusion: compassionate courage

The owners we work with are rarely short of empathy. What they need is permission — and a method — to act on what they already know.

Loyalty deserves to be honoured. Coaching deserves to be tried, seriously and with a deadline. But a business is not a debt to be repaid to its earliest employees; it is a living system that must keep renewing its capability to survive. Keeping a person in a role they can no longer fill protects no one: not the owner, not the team, not the customers, and not the person themselves.

Be empathetic — but not at the cost of the business. It is fair, and often kind, to let people go with dignity and bring new blood into the system.

[Download the full white paper] or write to us at gurbinder@smartroots.ae. We’d be glad to hear how your organisation is balancing employee loyalty, individual capability and business growth.

Let’s talk

If you recognise your business in these pages — a loyal team member the business has outgrown, a “coaching” conversation that has run for years, or a decision you keep postponing — you don’t have to work through it alone.

Smart Roots Consulting helps owners and leadership teams:

  • Assess the gap between the roles you have and the capability your next stage needs.
  • Coach with a contract — structured, time-bound development for long-tenured team members, using Stakeholder Centered Coaching.
  • Decide and act with dignity — fair exits, re-seating and communication that protect people, culture and reputation.
  • Renew the team — role design, hiring and onboarding of the capability the business needs next.

Start with a confidential 45-minute conversation. Message me on LinkedIn or visit gurbinderpunn.com.

About the author

Gurbinder Singh Punn is Founder and CEO of Smart Roots Consulting, a boutique People & Organisation Development consultancy working across the UAE, Oman and India. He brings decades of CHRO experience across India, the United States, Canada and the Middle East, and today works as an executive coach and group process facilitator with owners, family businesses and leadership teams.

He is the author of The Coaching Advantage and holds the ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC) and Advanced Certification in Team Coaching (ACTC), the IAF Certified Professional Facilitator (CPF) designation, and certification in Marshall Goldsmith Stakeholder Centered Coaching. He is a two-time Distinguished Toastmaster and a long-time mentor in his professional community.

Smart Roots Consulting — People & Organisation Development · UAE · Oman · India

References

Journals and research

  • Bies, R. J., & Moag, J. S. (1986). Interactional justice: Communication criteria of fairness. In R. J. Lewicki, B. H. Sheppard & M. H. Bazerman (Eds.), Research on Negotiation in Organizations, Vol. 1, 43–55. JAI Press.
  • Brockner, J. (1994). Perceived fairness and survivors’ reactions to layoffs, or how downsizing organizations can do well by doing good. Social Justice Research, 7(4), 345–363.
  • Felps, W., Mitchell, T. R., & Byington, E. (2006). How, when, and why bad apples spoil the barrel: Negative group members and dysfunctional groups. Research in Organizational Behavior, 27, 175–222.
  • Gómez-Mejía, L. R., Haynes, K. T., Núñez-Nickel, M., Jacobson, K. J. L., & Moyano-Fuentes, J. (2007). Socioemotional wealth and business risks in family-controlled firms. Administrative Science Quarterly, 52(1), 106–137.
  • Greiner, L. E. (1972; republished 1998). Evolution and revolution as organizations grow. Harvard Business Review.
  • Manzoni, J.-F., & Barsoux, J.-L. (1998). The set-up-to-fail syndrome. Harvard Business Review, March–April.
  • Rousseau, D. M. (1989). Psychological and implied contracts in organizations. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 2(2), 121–139.
  • Staw, B. M. (1976). Knee-deep in the big muddy: A study of escalating commitment to a chosen course of action. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 16(1), 27–44.
  • Staw, B. M., & Ross, J. (1987). Knowing when to pull the plug. Harvard Business Review, March–April.

Books and management experts

  • Brown, B. (2018). Dare to Lead. Random House.
  • Collins, J. (2001). Good to Great. HarperBusiness.
  • Goldsmith, M. (2007). What Got You Here Won’t Get You There. Hyperion.
  • Hastings, R., & Meyer, E. (2020). No Rules Rules: Netflix and the Culture of Reinvention. Penguin Press.
  • Hoffman, R., Casnocha, B., & Yeh, C. (2014). The Alliance: Managing Talent in the Networked Age. Harvard Business Review Press.
  • Horowitz, B. (2014). The Hard Thing About Hard Things. HarperBusiness.
  • McCord, P. (2017). Powerful: Building a Culture of Freedom and Responsibility. Silicon Guild.
  • Rousseau, D. M. (1995). Psychological Contracts in Organizations. Sage.
  • Scott, K. (2017). Radical Candor. St. Martin’s Press.
  • Wasserman, N. (2012). The Founder’s Dilemmas. Princeton University Press.

Other

  • Morrison, D. (2013). Video address to the Australian Army on unacceptable behaviour, June 2013.
  • Smart Roots Consulting client engagements, UAE, Oman and India (composite, anonymised).

Citations compiled from published sources; confirm page numbers and editions before external publication.

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related Posts